Artists sometimes confuse the two Justinas, so we will look at each
one separately and then discuss how their respective images may be
identified.
JUSTINA AND CYPRIAN OF ANTIOCH
The story of Justina and Cyprian of Antioch is told in the Golden
Legend. Originally Cyprian was a wicked magician who enlisted the
devil in his designs on the virtue of Justina, who had become a
Christian after hearing a priest read the gospel. The devil kept
trying, but every attempt failed when Justina would make the sign of
the Cross. The devil had to admit to Cyprian that "the crucified
God" was stronger than he, so Cyprian renounced his relationship
with the devil and became a Christian. Eventually he was made the
bishop of Antioch. Later Cyprian and Justina came to the attention
of the "earl of that country" (so Caxton; comes or "count"
in the Latin source; "prefect" in Ryan). He had them taken before him in
shackles, beaten, scourged, and cast into a great vat of boiling
pitch, wax, and tallow. When all this did not persuade them to
return to the worship of the gods, he sent to Caesar for a judgment.
The latter's order was to have the two beheaded.
JUSTINA AND PROSDOCIMUS OF PADUA
The
Justina martyred in Padua was well renowned in late antiquity. In
the 6th century the Paduans dedicated a church to her and she was
among the virgin martyrs portrayed in the
presbytery arch in the Euphrasian Basilica (at left) and in the
procession of virgins in Sant'Apollinare Nuovo. In the 7th
century, Venantius Fortunatus, writing in Gaul, urged travelers to
Padua to visit her relics there.1
This saint is not, however, represented in the Golden Legend. A
Latin life in the Acta Sanctorum says she was baptized in
the first century by St. Prosdocimus. Later the story has her
arrested at a marble bridge near Padua and brought before the
Emperor, anachronistically named Maximian.2
When she refuses to sacrifice to Mars he orders her put to the sword
in the Campus Martius, the very field that is today overlooked by
her church, the Abbey of Santa Giustina.3
Although the instrument of death was a sword (in the Latin a gladius
or short sword, as in these
images), this Justina was not beheaded. Instead, she knelt
down and the executioner stabbed her in the side, leaving her alive
for an hour, during which she cast her eyes repeatedly to Heaven,
praying that God would receive her soul.
NARRATIVE IMAGES
The images most obviously related to Justina of Padua are those at
Santa Giustina in Padua. On the doors of the church we see modern
reliefs of her baptism by Prosdocimus and her martyrdom:

|
Left: St. Prosdocimus baptizes
Justina. The tablet held behind him reads Ego te
baptizo, "I baptize you." The ewer becomes his
attribute in other images (examples).
Right: The martyrdom. The executioner stands behind
Justina's shoulder as he prepares to plunge his gladius
into her side, following the command of the emperor
seated on the left.
|
The stance of the executioner in the door
relief and the plunging of the sword repeat the pattern in
this painting of the Padua martyrdom.
The executioner stands behind the saint's shoulder and
plunges the short sword into Justina's breast. Her eyes
are already cast toward Heaven, as in the story. In the
background is the marble bridge where she was arrested.
Clearly this is the Paduan Justina, yet the artist may
have been influenced by images of the other Justina's
passion. The men on the left wear "oriental" garb –
turbans on the two white men and a Phrygian cap on the
black executioner. The clothes of the young man on the
right also seem more suitable for a comes than for
an emperor.
And could the inclusion of an old man on the right be due
to a portrayal of Cyprian in an Antiochene painting? In
the portrait of Cyprian below
the saint does indeed have a long gray beard like this
man.
|

Attrib. Paolo Veronese, "The Martyrdom of St.
Justina," Uffizi Gallery, Florence. (This image has a page of its
own.) |
Another painting of the execution at Padua is
displayed inside Santa Giustina. This work also places the
executioner behind the saint's shoulder, though in this case
the sword is not visible.
As in the Uffizi painting Justina's eyes are cast up to
Heaven, where indeed the angels have already been sent to
answer her prayer and bring her the martyr's palm. As
specified in the story, she is kneeling as she prays.
The church in the background is Santa Giustina itself,
establishing the locale of the foreground as the Campus
Martius (today the Prato della Valle).3
As in the other martyrdom painting, a few details hint at an
Antiochene influence. The executioner is again an African,
and the man in authority wearing the engraved breastplate at
the far left is dressed more like the comes who
condemned Justina of Antioch than the emperor who ordered
the executions in Padua. Also, the shackles on the saint's
wrists are from the Antiochene passion; there are none in
the Paduan. |

Paolo Veronese, The Martyrdom
of St. Justina
|

|
The passion of Justina of Antioch is
portrayed much less frequently. I have found none in my
travels and only one online. The image on the left shows
Justina and Cyprian in the vat of boiling fluids that Count
Eutolmius has ordered for them. Cyprian wears a rather
ill-fitting mitre. On the right, the bearded man in the fur
robe and hat is most likely the Count.
The man in green assailed by flames on the far right is the
pagan priest Athanasius, who thought he could show the power
of the gods by entering the vat himself. Unfortunately, as
soon as he approached the fire it leapt out and destroyed
him.
The man in the red hat conversing with Eutolmius should be
his cousin Terentius. Seeing that neither beatings nor fire
could persuade the two Christians, he advised the Count to
send to Caesar for a judgment.
Surprisingly, this image has no orientalizing touches, with
the possible exception of the Count's round fur hat. This
was part of the uniform of hussars in the 18th century,
which is the probable era of the image. (The tricorne hats
worn by the other two men are characteristic of the 18th
century in the west.)
|
PORTRAITS
Andrea Mantegna, detail from
the San Luca altarpiece, 1453
(This image in full
resolution)
|
Portraits of Justina of Padua tend to be like
the one shown here on the left, with a palm branch and a
short sword driven into the side of the chest.
For portraits unquestionably of Justina of Antioch, I have
found only some Eastern Orthodox icons, which typically put
a cross in her hand. The cross refers to the episodes in
which she made the sign of the cross as a defense against
the blandishments of the demons. The icons pair this Justina
with Cyprian, who is represented as an old man in episcopal
vestments, as at right.
|

Romanian icon posted
on Wikimedia Commons
|
|
In the West portraits of "Justina" sometimes
seriously confuse the two saints. The image at right, for
example, portrays three saints whose feast is on October 7:
The soldier saints Serge and Bacchus, and Justina of Padua.
The latter stands on a great demon, signifying her victory
over the blandishments of the devils sent by Cyprian to
tempt her. But it was Justina of Antioch who withstood those
blandishments.
|

|
 |
A statue in the west portal of the Franciscan
Church in Vienna is identified by the photographer, a
historian, as Justina of Padua. But in her left hand the
saint holds a demon. This is most likely an allusion to the
Antiochene story. Furthermore, the sword in her right hand
is not the short gladius that killed Justina of
Padua but more like the full-length sword that is an
attribute of saints who were beheaded – for example St. Paul and St. Catherine of
Alexandria. Thus it would be difficult to say with
certainty which Justina is being portrayed.
|
 |

|
Finally, a painting titled "Justina and the
Unicorn" could go either way. According to Honorius of Autun
a unicorn though wild will tamely place its head in the lap
of a virgin, just as Christ prizes chastity and chose the
Virgin Mary in the Incarnation (Sill
26-27). The unicorn here may therefore reference Justina of
Antioch's steadfast defense of her chastity and perhaps her
remark to her suitor (in the Latin version) that she is
already wed to Christ ("De SS.
Cypriano, Iustina et Theoctisto," 243).
However, it is a commonplace that virgin martyrs are brides
of Christ of unimpeachable chastity, so Justina of Padua
cannot really be ruled out. In this connection it may be
noted that her hair is styled just like that of the Paduan
saint in the Euphrasian basilica (see
above).
The Web Gallery of Art suggests that the kneeling man is the
donor.
(This image in full resolution)
|
Feast days: October 7 for Cyprian and Justina of Antioch, September
26 for Justina and Prosdocimus of Padua
Hagiography:
For
Antioch, Golden Legend #142: html
or pdf; "De SS. Cypriano,
Iustina et Theoctisto" in Acta
Sanctorum, Sept. vol. 7, 195-246.
For Padua, "De Sancta Iustina V. M." in Acta Sanctorum, Oct.
vol. 3, 790-826.
Prepared in 2014 by Richard Stracke, Emeritus Professor of
English, at Augusta University
HOME PAGE
|